Publishing Journal ›› 2025, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (3): 64-72.
Previous Articles
School of Information Management, Zhengzhou University;
School of Education, Zhengzhou University
Received:
Revised:
Online:
Published:
Abstract: To promote the value diffusion and knowledge dissemination of academic books, and assist in the construction of China’ s independent knowledge system, this article explores the mechanism for the deep participation of academic community in the value revealing of academic books. This paper analyzes the logical relationship between the academic community and the value revealing of academic books. At the same time, it constructs a value revealing model that can deeply explore the knowledge contribution of academic books, with the academic community as the main body, the platform integrating digital technology as the carrier, and the moral and institutional norms as the guarantee. From the process of the academic books’ production and dissemination, value discovery and negotiation, value authentication and recommendation, as well as value diffusion and knowledge reproduction, this paper constructs operational mechanism of the value revealing of academic books from the perspective of academic community. Besides, in order to promote the participation of academic community in the value revealing of academic books, this paper proposes three suggestions, which includes implementing the dominant role of the academic community, promoting high-quality data construction, and creating a good academic evaluation environment.
Key words: Academic community Book evaluation Academic value Peer review Value revealing model
CLC Number:
G237
Zhou Chunlei Xue Ning Li Yanbo Wang Qiaohong. Research on the Model and Operational Mechanism of the Value Revealing of Academic Books from the Perspective of the Academic Community[J]. Publishing Journal, 2025, 33(3): 64-72.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Reference Manager|ProCite|BibTeX|RefWorks
URL: https://cbkx.whu.edu.cn/jwk3/cbkx/EN/
https://cbkx.whu.edu.cn/jwk3/cbkx/EN/Y2025/V33/I3/64
与情报,2021(2):108-116
[9]Kousha K, Thelwall M, Abdoli M.Goodreads reviews to assess the wider impacts of books[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2017,68(8):2004-2016 [10] 刘敬涛,李秀霞,邵作运 . 一种基于主题提取和情感分析的图书评价方法 [J]. 情报探索,2022(5):43-49 [11] 周清清,章成志 . 图书影响力评价研究进展与展望 [J]. 大学图书馆学报,2020,38(3):24-33 [12][30] 蒋颖 . 中文学术图书评价的瓶颈与突破 :基于图书生命周期视角的分析 [J]. 中国社会科学评价,2022, (4):133-144+158 [13][27] 张志强,尹召凯 . 中国学术图书评价 :主要问题、策略审视与议题共识 [J]. 现代出版,2020(4): 16-22 [14] 叶继元 . 学术全评价体系论 [M]. 北京 :社会科学文献出版社,2021 :109-122 [15] 徐拥军,陈晓婷 . 自然评价模式的基本框架与运行机制研究 [J]. 甘肃社会科学,2023(4):27-35 [16] 韩启德 . 学术共同体当承担学术评价重任 [N]. 光明日报,2009-10-12(10) [17] 王浩斌 . 学术共同体、学术期刊与学术评价之内在逻辑解读 [J]. 中国社会科学评价,2015(3):69- 81+126-127 [18] 索传军,盖双双 . 单篇学术论文的评价本质、问题及新视角分析 [J]. 情报杂志,2018,37(6):102-107 [19] 邱均平 . 人文社会科学评价理论与实践(上册)[M]. 武汉 :武汉大学出版社,2012 :537 [20] 万彩红 . 古人的图书价值观及其影响 [J]. 图书与情报,2007(1):116-119 [21] 尹杰 . 图书价值论 [J]. 武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版),2013,26(6):957-960 [22] 邱均平 . 评价学 :理论·方法·实践 [M]. 北京 :科学出版社,2010 :5 [23] 默顿著 ;鲁旭东,林聚任译 . 科学社会学(上册)[M]. 北京 :商务印书馆,2010 :363 [24] 杨佳乐,胡乐明 . 知识生产过程、学术评价变革与自主知识体系构建 [J]. 学习与探索,2024(11):41-50 [25] 周春雷 . 试析现行学术评价体系的运作机理 [J]. 中国科技期刊研究,2012,23(6):1013-1016 [26] 周春雷,孟丽慧,李彦博,等 . 学术授信分析 :模型、方法及应用 [J]. 档案管理,2022(2):21-25 [28] 邱均平,张裕晨,周子番 . 新时代我国科研评价体系重构中必须处理好八大关系 [J]. 中国图书馆学报, 2021,47(1):47-60 [29] 周春雷,王倩倩,李彦博 . 学术共同体视角下的审稿人学术话语权运行机制与优化策略研究 [J]. 中国科技 期刊研究,2024,35(1):53-58 [31] 王丰年 . 论我国学术文献数据库的质量调控 [J]. 出版广角,2017(4):28-31