出版科学 ›› 2013, Vol. 21 ›› Issue (1): 15-21.

• 博士论坛 • 上一篇    下一篇

公共效用与权力作用构造:从“作品”到“著作权”的功能性分析

李杨   

  • 出版日期:2013-01-15 发布日期:2013-01-15
  • 作者简介:李杨,法学博士,南昌航空大学文法学院副教授。
  • 基金资助:

    本文系南昌航空大学博士科研启动基金“著作财产权体系中的个人使用问题研究”(EA201214045)阶段性研究成果。

Functional Analysis on the Construction of Public Utility and Power: from
Works to  Copyright

Li Yang   

  • Online:2013-01-15 Published:2013-01-15

摘要:

作品的非物质性、非稀缺性与非竞争性、有益外部性与互文性表明,著作权对象具有公共效用属性,具有一定财产内在结构缺陷,难以确立并保持稳定的财产权界限。著作权在给权利人激励与必要回报的基础上,最终以实现作品社会价值最大化的公共福利为根本目的,主要体现在文化参与功能和民主政治功能两个层面。在确立著作权的边界时,应从著作权人的单一主体模式转变为著作权人、传播者、使用者的多元主体模式,进而实现著作权作为财产利益的“分配伦理”。仅从作品出发,期望能人为设立“独创性”“思想/表达二分法”的著作权对象保护标准的想法,并不能一劳永逸地解决著作权的权利作用“焦点”困境。为了确立著作权的边界,在权利作用构造上既要考虑作为对象的作品范围问题,更应侧重于以“使用行为”作为权利作用“焦点”的切入点和核心依据。“传播”是著作权人实现作品利益的主要利用方式,即传播权是著作权体系的基础性权利。

关键词: 作品,  著作权,  公共效用,  权利作用&ldquo, 焦点&rdquo,  传播

Abstract:

 Characteristics of works, such as immateriality, non-scarcity, non-rivalness, positive externalities and intertextuality, make clear that subject matter of copyright has the property of public utility and inherent defect of property structure. It is difficult to radicate and preserve stable boundary lines of property rights in copyright system. By stimulating and paying back to rightholders, the primary purpose of copyright is designed to realizing public welfare maximum of works, embodied in cultural participatory function and democratic politics function. As determiming the boundary of copyright, we should transform from single-subject model to plural-subject model for realizing the distribution ethics of copyright interests among authors, communicators and users. As far as copyright are concerned,the path to subject matter for locating focal point of copyright functions is a vague historic conception which is difficult to define the boundaries of copyright and it can not resolve the focal point dilemma of copyright functions once and for all. The path to controlled object ( behaviors of works use ) is always through the main line of focal point of copyright functions. Dissemination is the uppermost utilization pattern of works. In a word,the right of dissemination is the basic right of copyright.

Key words: Works,  Copyright,  Public utility,  Focus of rights function,  Dissemination