虚拟现实媒介：一种新型叙事平台及其隐私挑战

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 探索虚拟现实媒介沉浸性、交互性和想象力三大特性在叙事中的表现，阐明其对传统叙事方式的革新性影响。揭示在身临其境的创新体验背后，隐私挑战日益突出，需要解决的隐私问题包括：数据泄露可能导致用户信息被不必要地泄露，心理操控可能导致心理伤害，空间隐私的侵犯可能削弱用户自主权等。最后，从技术、伦理和法律的角度深入讨论隐私保护的可能路径，以期为虚拟现实媒介中平衡用户体验和隐私安全的叙事实践提供参考。

Abstract:

Exploring the three characteristics of virtual reality media, namely immersiveness, interactivity and imagination, in narrative, and elucidating its revolutionizing impact on traditional narrative approaches.It reveals that privacy challenges are increasingly prominent behind immersive and innovative experiences, and privacy issues that need to be addressed include data leakage that may lead to unnecessary disclosure of user information, psychological manipulation that may lead to psychological harm, and violation of spatial privacy that may weaken user autonomy. Finally, possible paths of privacy protection are discussed in depth from technical, ethical and legal perspectives, with a view to informing narrative practices that balance user experience and privacy security in virtual reality media.

中图分类号:

G231

梁斯婷　徐丽芳. 虚拟现实媒介：一种新型叙事平台及其隐私挑战[J]. 出版科学, 2024, 32(06): 5-14.

Liang Siting　Xu Lifang. Virtual Reality Media: A New Narrative Platform and Its Privacy Challenges[J]. Publishing Journal, 2024, 32(06): 5-14.

参考文献

[1] 徐丽芳，田峥峥，何倩 . 虚拟现实媒介研究综述 [J]. 出版科学，2022，30（6）：77-89
[2][31] 艾瑞咨询 . 2024 年中国虚拟现实行业研究报告 [R/OL]. [2024-03-21]. https ：//www.idigital.com.
cn/report/4326?type=0
[3][47] VR 陀螺 . 对隐私安全后知后觉的 VR 产业，正将用户拖入“黑客帝国”时代 [EB/OL]. [2020-07-30].
https ：//www.jiemian.com/article/4750019.html
[4] 南方都市报 . 未成年少女称在元宇宙被“轮奸”，英国受理虚拟世界犯罪首案 [EB/OL]. [2024-01-08].
https ：//new.qq.com/rain/a/20240108A070U100
[5] Warren S， Brandeis L. The right to privacy[M].Killing the Messenger ： 100 Years of Media Criticism.
Columbia University Press， 1989 ：193
[6] Nissenbaum H. Toward an approach to privacy in public ： Challenges of information
technology[J]. Ethics & Behavior， 1997， 7（3）： 207-219
[7][10] Canbay Y， Utku A， Canbay P. Privacy concerns and measures in metaverse ： A review[C]//2022
15th International Conference on Information Security and Cryptography（ ISCTURKEY） . IEEE， 2022 ：
80-85
[8][11][12] Gallardo A， Choy C， Juneja J， et al. Speculative privacy concerns about AR glasses
data collection[J]. Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies， 2023（4）：416-435
[9][45] Solove D J. Conceptualizing privacy[J]. California Law Review， 2002， 90 ：1087-1155
[13][48][57] The Future of privacy forum. Risk Framework for Body-Related Data in Immersive
Technologies[EB/OL]. [2023-12-12].https ：//fpf.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/FPF-RiskFramework-for-Body-Related-Data-FINAL-Digital.pdf
[14][58]
John B， Koppal S， Jain E. EyeVEIL ： degrading iris authentication in eye tracking
headsets[C]//Proceedings of the 11th ACM Symposium on Eye Tracking Research & Applications，
2019 ：1-5
[15][59][61] Intel. 什么是边缘计算 ?[EB/OL]. [2024-01-10]. https ：//www.intel.cn/content/www/cn/zh/
edge-computing/what-is-edge-computing.html
[16] Gedeon J， Brandherm F， Egert R， et al. What the fog? edge computing revisited ： Promises，
applications and future challenges[J]. IEEE Access， 2019（7）：152847-152878
[17][60] Lu R， Heung K， Lashkari A H， et al. A lightweight privacy-preserving data aggregation
scheme for fog computing-enhanced IoT[J]. IEEE Access， 2017（5）： 3302-3312
[18] Shi C， Xu X， Zhang T， et al. Face-Mic ： inferring live speech and speaker identity via subtle facial
dynamics captured by AR/VR motion sensors[C]//Proceedings of the 27th Annual International
Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking， 2021 ： 478-490
[19][51] Buck L E， Bodenheimer B. Privacy and personal space ： Addressing interactions and
interaction data as a privacy concern[C]//2021 IEEE Conference on Virtual Reality and 3D User
Interfaces Abstracts and Workshops（ VRW）. IEEE， 2021 ： 399-400
[20] David M. O’Brien. Privacy， Law， and Public Policy[M]. New York ： Praeger Special Studies， 1979 ：
13-14
[21][65] Dremliuga R， Dremliuga O， Iakovenko A. Virtual reality ： general issues of legal regulation[J].
Journal of Politics and Law， 2020， 13 ： 75
[22][38][66] George A S. Virtual Violence ： Legal and Psychological Ramiffcations of Sexual Assault in
Virtual Reality Environments[J]. Partners Universal International Innovation Journal， 2024， 2（1）： 96-
114
[23][64] Hansen J. Virtual indecent assault ： Time for the criminal law to enter the realm of virtual
reality[J]. Victoria University of Wellington Law Review， 2019， 50（1）： 57-76
[24][55] López B R. Ethics of Virtual Reality[M]//Ethics of Artiffcial Intelligence. Cham ： Springer Nature
Switzerland， 2024 ： 109-127
[25][70] 闫炜炜 . 歧视与隐私：虚拟现实技术潜在的数字正义风险探析 [J]. 科技传播，2023，15（15）：79-
81+86
[26][27] 陈霖，何青颖 . 数字叙事：想象世界的方式 [J]. 探索与争鸣，2024（9）：157-165+180
[28] Burdea G C， Coiffet P. Virtual Reality Technology[M]. John Wiley & Sons， 2024 ：3
[29] 徐丽芳，陈铭，赵雨婷 . 数字出版概论 [M]. 武汉：武汉大学出版社， 2022 ：91-92
[30][39] Vista. An Introduction to Immersive Technologies[EB/OL].[2024-01-01].https ：//www.
vistaequitypartners.com/insights/an-introduction-to-immersive-technologies
[32] The Future of privacy forum. Understanding Extended Reality Technology& Data Flows [EB/OL].
[2022-10-31].https ：//fpf.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/XR-Infographic-Screen-reader-friendlyversion.pdf
[33]
The Future of privacy forum. Understanding Extended Reality Technology& Data Flows ： XR
Functions [EB/OL]. [2023-06-20].https ：//fpf.org/blog/understanding-extended-reality-technologydata-ﬂows-xr-functions
[34][35]
方卿，涂琪瑾，丁靖佳 . 虚拟现实媒介及其叙事形式分析 [J]. 出版广角，2023（7）：4-10
[36] Nash K. Virtual reality witness ： exploring the ethics of mediated presence[J]. Studies in
Documentary Film， 2018， 12（2）： 119-131
[37] Sun W， Banakou D， Świdrak J， et al. Multisensory experiences of affective touch in virtual reality
enhance engagement， body ownership， pleasantness， and arousal modulation[J]. Virtual Reality，
2024（ 28）：1-16
[40][41] Hadjipanayi C， Christofi M， Banakou D， et al. Cultivating empathy through narratives in
virtual reality ： a review[J]. Personal and Ubiquitous Computing， 2024（28）： 1-13
[42] 蒋花，张勇 . 叙事移情理论 [C]// 认知诗学第 3 辑 . 四川外国语大学国际教育学院，2018 ：10
[43][54] Handwiki. Psychological Manipulation[EB/OL]. [2022-10-28]. https ：//encyclopedia.pub/

entry/31801

[44] 付军龙 . 叙事语言中的隐喻 [J]. 学术交流，2007（8）：129-132
[46] The Future of privacy forum. Understanding extended reality technology& data ﬂows ：privacy
and data protection risks and mitigation strategies[EB/OL]. [2022-11-17].https ：//fpf.org/blog/
understanding-extended-reality-technology-data-flows-privacy-and-data-protection-risks-andmitigation-strategies
[49]
Ravi B. Privacy issues in virtual reality ： eye tracking technology[EB/OL]. [2017-10-11]. https ：//
news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/privacy-issues-in-virtual-reality-eye-tracking-technology-1
[50] 王中贝 . 数字孪生技术道德化研究 [D]. 北京：中国科学技术大学，2023 ：61
[52] Maloney D， Zamanifard S， Freeman G. Anonymity vs. familiarity ： Self-disclosure and privacy
in social virtual reality[C]//Proceedings of the 26th ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and
Technology， 2020 ： 1-9
[53]Sykownik P， Maloney D， Freeman G， et al. Something personal from the metaverse ： goals，
topics， and contextual factors of self-disclosure in commercial social VR[C]//Proceedings of the
2022 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems， 2022 ： 1-17
[56] 张旭，王金柱 . 隐私的空间现象学 [J]. 江淮论坛，2024，（04）：128-134
[62] Fournier R， Freeling B， Gervilla M， et al. VR authentication through 3D key block
building[C]//2023 IEEE Conference on Virtual Reality and 3D User Interfaces Abstracts and Workshops
（VRW）. IEEE， 2023 ： 937-938
[63] Alismail A， Altulaihan E， Rahman M M H， et al. A systematic literature review on cybersecurity
threats of virtual reality（ vr） and augmented reality（ ar）[J]. Data Intelligence and Cognitive Informatics ：
Proceedings of ICDICI ，2022 ： 761-774
[67] 沈国华，魏联宇，谢明博 . 基于感知（皮肤电反应：GSR）智能的影视观众心理研究方法与路径初探 [J].
文艺争鸣，2023（2）：201-208
[68] Kenwright B. Virtual reality ： ethical challenges and dangers [opinion][J]. IEEE Technology and
Society Magazine， 2018， 37（4）： 20-25
[69] O’Brolcháin F， Jacquemard T， Monaghan D， et al. The convergence of virtual reality and
social networks ： threats to privacy and autonomy[J]. Science and engineering ethics， 2016（22）：
1-29